A block that is half melting ice and half solid fat, sitting in a puddle of water

It's one of the most satisfying screenshots online: a bathroom scale on day one of a long fast, and the same scale a few days later, several kilos lighter. And it's one of the most deflating experiences offline: eating normally again and watching part of that number creep back within days.

Nothing has gone wrong when that happens. It's the body doing something entirely predictable. The interesting part is what the lost weight was made of in the first place.

What the evidence shows

Not all of it is fat. A 2024 review of human trials on water-only and very-low-calorie fasts lasting 5 to 20 days found that people lost between 2% and 10% of their body weight. But roughly two-thirds of that loss was "lean mass" and only about a third was fat (Ezpeleta et al., Nutrition Reviews, 2024).

"Lean mass" sounds like muscle, but on a body-composition report it simply means everything that isn't fat: water, organs, muscle, and glycogen — the carbohydrate your liver and muscles keep in reserve, packed together with water.

One study took that lean loss apart. Sixteen healthy men did a supervised ten-day fast on 200-250 calories a day, with daily walks and gentle exercise. They lost about 5.9 kg. Around 40% of it was fat and 60% was lean tissue. And of that lean part, close to half was water outside the cells (including some lost through the enemas used in that programme), about a seventh was glycogen with its water, and the rest — roughly a quarter of the total weight lost — was working tissue such as muscle and organs (Laurens et al., Journal of Cachexia, Sarcopenia and Muscle, 2021). The men's strength held up.

A scan-based study of 32 people on a 12-day fast found something similar in muscle: the calf shrank by about 5%, an amount the researchers said largely matched the glycogen and water they'd expect to be lost. Muscle strength and function were preserved (Naëgel et al., Journal of Cachexia, Sarcopenia and Muscle, 2025).

That's why the scale rebounds so quickly. In a study of 13 men who fasted completely for ten days, fat mass kept falling, but lean mass started to recover during just four days of gradual refeeding (Dai et al., Nutrients, 2022). The water-and-glycogen part of the "loss" was never fat to begin with, and the body restocks it once food returns.

What's left weeks later? This is where it gets genuinely interesting. Three months after the ten-day fast, the men were still lighter — but their fat mass was back to where it started, and their waist measurement had returned too. What stayed lower was lean tissue (Laurens et al., 2021).

A 2026 randomised trial found close to the opposite. Thirty-eight healthy adults did a five-day, 200-250-calorie fast. Twelve weeks later, the lean mass they'd lost had fully returned, part of the weight had come back, and what remained lost was mostly fat (Kaufhold et al., Genome Medicine, 2026).

Both studies agree on one thing: most blood-sugar, blood-pressure and cholesterol improvements had faded by around three months. The 2024 review saw the same pattern across trials, even in people who kept the weight off (Ezpeleta et al., 2024).

Why scientists still disagree

Two careful studies, two different answers. There are a few honest reasons.

First, measuring the body during a fast is hard. Fasting shifts the body's water around, and that confuses the machines that estimate fat and lean mass. The ten-day study said outright that its body-composition device couldn't be trusted during the fast, so its team estimated the breakdown from urine tests and figures from earlier research. The five-day trial used a different method altogether.

Second, the studies are small and different. Sixteen men with daily exercise and enemas are not the same as 38 adults of both sexes on a shorter fast.

Third, nobody has done the obvious comparison: a multi-day fast versus a slower diet with the same total calorie deficit, measured the same way for a year.

It's worth knowing that ordinary intermittent fasting — eating windows, 5:2, alternate days — behaves more like a normal diet. Across 24 trials of at least six months, involving 2,032 adults, most of the weight lost was fat, and results were comparable to standard calorie restriction (Khalafi et al., Obesity Reviews, 2025).

What you'll hear online

"I lost 4 kilos of fat in five days." Some of it was fat. A good share was water and stored carbohydrate that will return.

"The weight came back, so fasting doesn't work." Water coming back isn't failure; it's refilling. What matters is the trend over weeks.

"Long fasts burn your muscle." Some lean tissue is lost, but in these small studies strength held up, and in one trial lean mass fully recovered.

Before believing any fasting claim, it helps to ask five quick questions:

Five questions before you believe a fasting claim

  1. Was this seen in people, or in mice?
  2. How many people, and for how long?
  3. Compared to what?
  4. Did they measure a real outcome, or a number in the blood?
  5. Does the person telling me this sell something related? (Not an accusation — just useful to know.)

Here, question two matters most: "for how long" decides whether you're looking at water, or at fat.

What would actually settle it

A randomised trial comparing a five- to ten-day fast with a gradual diet that creates the same total calorie deficit, measuring body composition with the best available scans and body-water tests at one, three, six and twelve months — in women, men and people over 60. It's a straightforward question that's surprisingly unanswered, and worth funding.

What you can do

If you try a longer fast, judge it by your weight and waist four to six weeks later, not by the number on day five. Anyone taking regular medication, or with diabetes, kidney problems or a history of disordered eating, should only consider a multi-day fast with their doctor's involvement. See Before you fast on medication: the questions to ask your doctor and Inside a multi-day water fast: what happens in your body, day by day.

The scale is a blunt instrument. It weighs water, food and fat all together, and it can't tell you which one moved. That's not a reason to ignore it — just a reason to give it time.

— Dr. Brugal

Voices in the debate

If you'd like to hear the case for fasting from doctors who champion it, these are some of the most influential voices. Their views often go beyond what published human trials have shown so far — which is exactly why it's worth hearing them and checking the studies side by side.

  • Dr Jason Fung — MD, nephrologist (Canada), who supports supervised longer fasts as a tool against obesity and type 2 diabetes; author of The Complete Guide to Fasting.
  • Prof Andreas Michalsen — MD PhD, internal and nutritional medicine at Charité Berlin, who advocates therapeutic fasting combined with healthy eating for chronic disease; author of The Fasting Fix. Penguin Random House

For the wider debate, see our series guide: Why scientists still can't agree on fasting — and what would settle it.

References

All studies retrieved via PubMed.

  1. Ezpeleta M, Cienfuegos S, Lin S, et al. Efficacy and safety of prolonged water fasting: a narrative review of human trials. Nutrition Reviews. 2024;82(5):664-675. Narrative review of human trials. doi:10.1093/nutrit/nuad081 (PMID 37377031)
  2. Laurens C, Grundler F, Damiot A, et al. Is muscle and protein loss relevant in long-term fasting in healthy men? A prospective trial on physiological adaptations. Journal of Cachexia, Sarcopenia and Muscle. 2021;12(6):1690-1703. Uncontrolled study, 16 healthy men, 10-day fast, 3-month follow-up. doi:10.1002/jcsm.12766 (PMID 34668663)
  3. Naëgel A, Viallon M, Ratiney H, et al. Impact of Long-Term Fasting on Skeletal Muscle: Structure, Energy Metabolism and Function Using 31P/1H MRS and MRI. Journal of Cachexia, Sarcopenia and Muscle. 2025;16(2):e13773. Uncontrolled study, 32 people, 12-day fast. doi:10.1002/jcsm.13773 (PMID 40211897)
  4. Dai Z, Zhang H, Wu F, et al. Effects of 10-Day Complete Fasting on Physiological Homeostasis, Nutrition and Health Markers in Male Adults. Nutrients. 2022;14(18):3860. Uncontrolled study, 13 men, 10-day complete fast plus refeeding. doi:10.3390/nu14183860 (PMID 36145236)
  5. Kaufhold G, Bartolomaeus TUP, Schütte K, et al. Machine learning identifies microbiome and clinical predictors of sustained weight loss following prolonged fasting. Genome Medicine. 2026;18(1). Randomised waitlist-controlled trial, 38 healthy adults, 5-day fast, 12-week follow-up. doi:10.1186/s13073-026-01765-0 (PMID 42754908)
  6. Khalafi M, Maleki AH, Ehsanifar M, et al. Longer-term effects of intermittent fasting on body composition and cardiometabolic health in adults with overweight and obesity: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Obesity Reviews. 2025;26(2):e13855. Meta-analysis of 24 studies, 2,032 adults. doi:10.1111/obr.13855 (PMID 39501676)

Awareness content — not medical advice. Always talk to your doctor or pharmacist before making changes.