
For years, Peter Attia, a well-known longevity doctor and podcaster, regularly went without food for days at a time, drinking only water. Then he looked at scans of his own body composition, saw how much lean tissue he was losing, and stopped. As he has explained on his podcast, the trade-off no longer seemed worth it to him.
That's a striking change of heart from someone who'd tried it more than most. It's also a good way into a question many people ask: what actually happens inside you when you stop eating for several days?
The answer is genuinely fascinating. It's also not quite the story you'll hear online.
First, some words
Experts only agreed on shared definitions for fasting in 2024. Fasting for two to three days now counts as short-term; four days or more is prolonged (Koppold et al., Cell Metabolism, 2024). So a "multi-day water fast" usually means one of these two — with nothing but water.
What happens, day by day
Much of what we know comes from classic medical studies of long, supervised fasts — many in people with obesity — summarised in a 2025 review of fasting physiology (Rebello et al., International Journal of Obesity, 2025).
At first: running on stored sugar. Your body draws on its sugar stores while insulin, the hormone that tells you to store energy, starts to fall. Lower insulin releases the brake on a back-up system: your liver begins turning fat into ketones, an alternative fuel.
Around day three: the switch. Blood sugar reaches its lowest point and then holds steady. By now the liver's ketone production is close to its maximum, and ketones in the blood have risen sharply. This is ketosis — real, measurable, and one of the biggest metabolic shifts the human body can make.
Days three to seven: muscles borrow the new fuel. In this window, ketones cover a large share — roughly half or more — of your muscles' energy needs. Then something clever happens: muscles switch to burning fat directly, leaving the ketones for the organs that need them most.
Beyond a week: the brain adapts. In landmark studies from the 1960s, in people fasting under medical supervision for over a month, ketones largely replaced sugar as the brain's main fuel. That's how humans survive long periods without food and keep their minds working.
It's a beautiful system. But it has a price.
What you actually lose
A 2024 review of human trials of water-only fasts lasting 5 to 20 days found weight loss of 2 to 10% — and that about two-thirds of the weight lost was lean mass, with only around a third fat (Ezpeleta et al., Nutrition Reviews, 2024). The authors, who include some of the field's best-known fasting researchers, called the amount of lean tissue lost a concern. The classic studies point the same way: in the first month of total fasting, protein loss accounted for nearly half of the weight lost (Rebello et al., 2025).
Blood pressure fell consistently. Blood sugar markers improved in people without diabetes — but not in people with type 1 or type 2 diabetes. And here's the part that rarely makes it into videos: three to four months after the fast, the metabolic benefits had disappeared, even in people who'd kept the weight off (Ezpeleta et al., 2024).
Side effects reported in trials included headaches, insomnia, hunger and metabolic acidosis — the blood becoming too acidic. In a Polish study of 12 middle-aged men on an eight-day water-only fast, the men reported feeling less stressed and well. But their blood showed dehydration, low sodium, high uric acid and falling calcium and magnesium, and the authors concluded that carrying on would have harmed them (Ogłodek & Pilis, Global Advances in Health and Medicine, 2021).
Why scientists still disagree
The biggest positive study has no comparison group. At the Buchinger Wilhelmi clinics, 1,422 people fasted for 4 to 21 days on 200–250 calories a day, under supervision, and fewer than 1% reported side effects (Wilhelmi de Toledo et al., PLOS ONE, 2019). That's reassuring about supervised fasting in a clinic — but it was observational, run by the clinic itself, and not a water-only fast.
Small studies. Many trials of prolonged fasting involve a dozen or a few dozen people.
Benefits that don't last. If the metabolic gains vanish within months, the honest question becomes: compared with what? A slower diet that keeps more muscle might do as well — nobody has tested that properly.
What you'll hear online
"After three days you reset your whole body." The switch to ketosis is real. A permanent reset isn't what the data show.
Before believing any fasting claim, it helps to ask five quick questions:
Five questions before you believe a fasting claim
- Was this seen in people, or in mice?
- How many people, and for how long?
- Compared to what?
- Did they measure a real outcome, or a number in the blood?
- Does the person telling me this sell something related? (Not an accusation — just useful to know.)
For multi-day fasts, add a sixth of your own: how much of that weight was muscle?
What would settle it
A randomised trial comparing a supervised multi-day fast with an ordinary low-calorie diet producing the same weight loss, with body-composition scans, muscle strength tests and at least a year of follow-up. It's very doable, and it would answer the question Attia ended up asking himself.
What you can do
If you're thinking about fasting for more than a couple of days, treat it as something closer to a medical procedure than a cleanse: do it only under medical supervision, and not at all without talking to your doctor if you take regular medication, have diabetes, are pregnant, or have a history of eating disorders. We're preparing Who should not fast — and the warning signs to stop.
Your body's ability to run on its own reserves is one of the most remarkable things about it. Respecting it means knowing what it costs.
Curiosity first.
— Dr. Brugal
Voices in the debate
If you'd like to hear the case for longer fasts from doctors who champion them, these are some of the most influential voices. Their views often go beyond what published human trials have shown so far — which is exactly why it's worth hearing them and checking the studies side by side.
- Dr Jason Fung — MD, nephrologist (Canada), who supports supervised prolonged fasts as a tool against obesity and type 2 diabetes. Book: The Complete Guide to Fasting.
- Prof Andreas Michalsen — MD PhD, internal and nutritional medicine at Charité Berlin, who combines therapeutic fasting with healthy eating to manage chronic conditions. Book: The Fasting Fix. Penguin Random House
- Dr Françoise Wilhelmi de Toledo — physician associated with the Buchinger Wilhelmi fasting clinics (Germany and Spain) and lead author of the 2019 study of 1,422 people described above, which reported supervised therapeutic fasting as safe and beneficial. PLOS ONE (PMC) · Buchinger Wilhelmi
For the wider debate, see our series guide: Why scientists still can't agree on fasting — and what would settle it. Related: Dry fasting: the trend with almost no evidence — and why that's the real story.
References
All studies retrieved via PubMed.
- Koppold DA, Breinlinger C, Hanslian E, et al. International consensus on fasting terminology. Cell Metabolism. 2024;36(8):1779-1794.e4. Expert consensus statement (38 experts). doi:10.1016/j.cmet.2024.06.013 (PMID 39059384)
- Rebello CJ, Zhang D, Anderson JC, et al. From starvation to time-restricted eating: a review of fasting physiology. International Journal of Obesity. 2025;49(1):43-48. Review, mostly of human starvation studies. doi:10.1038/s41366-024-01641-0 (PMID 39369112)
- Ezpeleta M, Cienfuegos S, Lin S, et al. Efficacy and safety of prolonged water fasting: a narrative review of human trials. Nutrition Reviews. 2024;82(5):664-675. Narrative review of human trials (fasts of 5–20 days). doi:10.1093/nutrit/nuad081 (PMID 37377031)
- Ogłodek E, Pilis W. Is water-only fasting safe? Global Advances in Health and Medicine. 2021;10:21649561211031178. Uncontrolled study, 12 men, 8-day water-only fast. doi:10.1177/21649561211031178 (PMID 34414015)
- Wilhelmi de Toledo F, Grundler F, Bergouignan A, et al. Safety, health improvement and well-being during a 4 to 21-day fasting period in an observational study including 1422 subjects. PLOS ONE. 2019;14(1):e0209353. Observational study, 1,422 people, no control group. doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0209353 (PMID 30601864)
On Peter Attia's change of approach (podcast The Drive, episode #353, June 2025, as summarised by Shortform and Hone Health) — secondary sources, not peer-reviewed.
Awareness content — not medical advice. Always talk to your doctor or pharmacist before making changes.