Footprints in wet sand being washed away by the incoming tide

Six weeks into a fasting plan, things feel great. Your clothes fit better, your blood test looks tidier, and you're telling friends about it. Eighteen months later, it's often a different picture — and you rarely see that part on social media.

That arc isn't just a personal story. It shows up in the research too, and it's one of the most important things to know before you start.

What the evidence shows

The 18-month trial. In Adelaide, Australia, 209 adults at higher risk of type 2 diabetes were split into three groups (Teong et al., Nature Medicine, 2023). One group fasted three non-consecutive days a week: they ate about 30% of their usual food between 8 am and midday, then nothing for 20 hours. Another cut their food by 30% every day. A third got a weight-loss booklet. The two diet groups had six months of nutrition support, and then everyone was followed for another year.

At six months, the fasting group was ahead. Their blood sugar after a test meal had improved more than in the daily-dieting group. By 18 months, that advantage was gone. Along the way, people in the fasting group also reported feeling tired more often.

Long water fasts. A 2024 review of human trials looked at fasts of 5 to 20 days on water alone (Ezpeleta et al., Nutrition Reviews, 2024). These fasts produced weight loss of 2–10% and lower blood pressure. But in the trials that checked afterwards, all the metabolic benefits had disappeared three to four months after the fast ended — even in people who had kept the weight off.

Edges that shrink with time. A large BMJ analysis of 99 trials with 6,582 adults found that alternate-day fasting had a small advantage over ordinary daily dieting (Semnani-Azad et al., BMJ, 2025). But in the 17 trials that lasted six months or more, that advantage didn't show up; only the benefit of dieting in any form, compared with eating freely, remained.

And mostly, we just don't know. The 2026 Cochrane review of intermittent fasting gathered 22 trials with 1,995 adults (Garegnani et al., Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews, 2026). Every one of them reported results for 12 months or less. For most fasting schedules, the 18-month question hasn't even been asked.

It's worth being clear about what "fade" means. Fasting didn't fail in these studies. In the Australian trial, by 18 months the fasting and daily-dieting groups had simply ended up level. The benefits were real; they just didn't outlast the effort.

Why scientists still disagree

Nobody knows for sure why the benefits fade, and the studies weren't designed to find out.

Effect or habit? In the Australian trial, support stopped at six months. So when the advantage disappeared, was it because the fasting stopped working, or because people stopped fasting? The data can't tell those apart.

Not just weight regain. In the water-fasting trials, the metabolic benefits vanished even when the weight stayed off. So, at least for long fasts, the improvements seem tied to the fasting period itself, not only to weight.

Too few long trials. Following people for years is slow and costly, and fewer people stay in a study the longer it runs. That's why most of what we know comes from the first few months — exactly when results look their best.

What you'll hear online

"I've kept the results for good." Some people genuinely do. But a before-and-after photo taken at 30 or 90 days can't tell you what happens at 18 months, and most published trials can't either.

"Do a long fast once or twice a year to reset your metabolism." In the water-fasting trials, the metabolic changes had faded within three to four months.

Before believing any fasting claim, it helps to ask five quick questions:

Five questions before you believe a fasting claim

  1. Was this seen in people, or in mice?
  2. How many people, and for how long — and did anyone check again later?
  3. Compared to what?
  4. Did they measure a real outcome, or a number in the blood?
  5. Does the person telling me this sell something related? (Not an accusation — just useful to know.)

What would actually settle it

Trials that follow people for two or three years, keep measuring after the support stops, record how many people are still fasting, and track real outcomes like a diabetes diagnosis rather than only blood tests. The Cochrane authors asked for follow-up beyond 12 months for exactly this reason. It's a question worth funding — because the answer decides whether fasting is a treatment or a phase.

What you can do

Before you start any fasting plan, ask yourself one question: could I still be doing this in 18 months? If the honest answer is no, pick something smaller that you could keep — for example, a longer overnight gap, as in The easiest fast: stop eating three hours before bed. And if you're choosing between schedules, 16:8, 5:2 or alternate days: which fasting schedule actually wins? looks at which ones people tend to stick with.

If you take regular medication, especially for diabetes or blood pressure, talk to your doctor before starting — Before you fast on medication: the questions to ask your doctor.

Six-month results make great headlines. Your health happens over the years after.

— Dr. Brugal

Voices in the debate

If you'd like to hear the case for fasting from doctors who champion it, these are some of the most influential voices. Their views often go beyond what published human trials have shown so far — which is exactly why it's worth hearing them and checking the studies side by side.

  • Prof Andreas Michalsen — MD PhD, Charité Berlin, internal and nutritional medicine, who champions therapeutic fasting combined with healthy eating to manage chronic conditions such as obesity, diabetes and heart disease. Book: The Fasting Fix. Penguin Random House
  • Dr Jason Fung — MD, nephrologist (Canada), who sees fasting as a central, long-term tool against obesity and type 2 diabetes. Book: The Obesity Code.
  • Dr Pradip Jamnadas — MD, cardiologist (Florida) and clinical assistant professor, who discusses fasting for heart and metabolic health in widely watched lectures. Feel Better, Live More (Bitesize)

For the wider debate, see our series guide: Why scientists still can't agree on fasting.

References

All studies retrieved via PubMed.

  1. Teong XT, Liu K, Vincent AD, et al. Intermittent fasting plus early time-restricted eating versus calorie restriction and standard care in adults at risk of type 2 diabetes: a randomized controlled trial. Nature Medicine. 2023;29(4):963-972. Randomised trial, 209 adults, 6 months plus 12-month follow-up. doi:10.1038/s41591-023-02287-7 (PMID 37024596)
  2. Ezpeleta M, Cienfuegos S, Lin S, et al. Efficacy and safety of prolonged water fasting: a narrative review of human trials. Nutrition Reviews. 2024;82(5):664-675. Narrative review of human trials. doi:10.1093/nutrit/nuad081 (PMID 37377031)
  3. Semnani-Azad Z, Khan TA, Chiavaroli L, et al. Intermittent fasting strategies and their effects on body weight and other cardiometabolic risk factors: systematic review and network meta-analysis of randomised clinical trials. BMJ. 2025;389:e082007. Network meta-analysis of 99 randomised trials, 6,582 adults. doi:10.1136/bmj-2024-082007 (PMID 40533200)
  4. Garegnani LI, Oltra G, Ivaldi D, et al. Intermittent fasting for adults with overweight or obesity. Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews. 2026;2(2):CD015610. Systematic review of 22 randomised trials, 1,995 adults. doi:10.1002/14651858.CD015610.pub2 (PMID 41692034)

Awareness content — not medical advice. Always talk to your doctor or pharmacist before making changes.